This morning I had a visit from a Jehovah’s Witness.
I had just returned home from grocery shopping and had put everything away. Brian was in the shower.
The man who showed up was an elderly fellow, and very sweet. He could see that I had my hands full (two little ones “hanging on my apron strings,” figuratively speaking); so he did try to keep his spiel short.
He showed me, in his New World Translation Bible, verses from Genesis, John…..a drawing in a little book of “heaven on earth,” showing people of all races living together in a Garden of Eden-like environment.
I’ve heard and seen all this before.
What is funny is that, just a week or two ago, I twice heard discussions on being prepared to talk to Jehovah’s Witnesses “when they show up at your door—and they will show up at your door.”
I thought they would never show up at my door.
Joke’s on me.
Several years ago, a friend of mine, whom I had met over the Internet, committed suicide. I traveled to Pennsylvania to help her husband and children for a couple of weeks after the funeral. I think I was really more “company” than “help,” for I was completely overwhelmed by the situation and had no clue where to begin with the mounds of laundry and cleaning that needed to be done; nor was I what you could call anything like a cook.
My friend’s husband had hired a housekeeper, though, thankfully. She was this wonderful black woman. Shortly upon making her acquaintance, I could tell she had a strong faith in the Lord, and I admired that in her very much. Being around her was like having a grounding place, a guiding light—when she was there, I felt like I could handle the terrible situation we were all in. She was a Jehovah’s Witness, and witness she did. She gave me several little books to read, as well as a copy of the J.W. translation of the Bible. And when I returned home, I found she had signed me up to receive copies of The Watchtower in the mail.
I was very grateful to her. Most of what she had to say made perfect sense to me. I’d been away from church pretty much since leaving home for college, and the experience of losing my friend to suicide (and seeing her husband’s somewhat frightening reaction to being left to raise four children) caused me to feel more adrift than I’d ever been. The Jehovah’s Witnesses newsletters were something of a lifeline—a voice of sanity during a time of real personal upheaval.
For a while, I seriously considered attending the J.W. meetings. But I thought it would be wise to first do some research into what they really believe—beyond what they present in their little door-to-door booklets and in their magazine. It didn’t take much doing to find out the truth. I also discussed it with my mom, who had gone through her own J.W. experience years before—when Mom told the J.W. lady she’d been doing Bible study with that she was not interested in becoming a Jehovah’s Witness, the woman told Mom she could no longer be friends with her, then. Sad.
Anyway, the interesting thing is that all this stuff with considering the Jehovah’s Witnesses is what set me on the course to discover the Truth. What is Truth? Where is Truth? Who is Truth? Etc. My mind had been opened. No longer did I feel that the only possible place to find and worship God was in the Evangelical Covenant church of my childhood. Ultimately, I decided I could take the leap of faith into the Lutheran church (the church of my husband’s childhood). And once I was there, my heart was ready to learn about and accept Catholicism.
Did I tell any of this to the gentleman at my door this morning?
No.
I wish I had. I wish I had had the courage to invite him in to talk. But I was so nervous—even after he left, it took a good half-hour for me to stop shaking. And Brian was home and probably would not have been pleased—he’s the type that would say “no thank you” immediately and shut the door in the person’s face.
I’m the type of person who always thinks of the great stuff to say after the conversation is long over. All day I’ve been thinking of things I would have liked to have discussed with this man. I would have liked to have heard about how he came to be a Jehovah’s Witness, to ask him questions about why he feels it’s the “right” church. I would have liked to have shared with him my love for the Catholic church.
He offered me a little booklet about how to read and understand the Bible. Then he thanked me for my honesty when I told him that if I took it from him, it would end up in the recycling bin. I said I would not read it because I already knew it would not be in keeping with my own faith. He said, “You mean ‘traditional thinking.’” As if there is something wrong with traditional Christianity!
Anyway, it is good that this happened today. I think I handled it very well—I was kind, I agreed with everything he said (after all, nothing he said was out of line with my own beliefs), and I let him know I was happy with my own church (I told him I was a new Catholic; he immediately assumed I had converted for my husband’s sake, so I set him straight on that!). But oh, the discussion could have been so much richer.
I know this now. Next time, I will be prepared!






Posted by Alan on May 29, 2008 at 5:54 pm
As one of Jehovah’s Christian Witnesses myself, I certainly want to thank you for your candid account. I would only ask that (that is, if you didn’t already know about this), when we visit with folks like you, we are not there to convert you. It is our thinking that we do not convert anyone, for because conversion means to change ones thinking, etc., it is our conviction that this is something which you can only do. No, but our intention is to only encourage ones to think about and reason on the Scriptures. Obviously, because we believe we have (only by God’s “grace”) the answers to most of life’s questions, this compels us to make the effort to share this knowledge/understanding with others. If, after your consideration, you do come to the conclusion that such still does not address your issues (including how God thinks about your friend or just why it is that God is waiting so long to bring about His promised Kingdom government, etc.), then fine, that’s ok with us – it all still remains your choice. Otherwise, we also believe that we are fulfilling Bible prophecy (Matt. 24:14), in obedience to Jehovah’s Son, Jesus, the Christ, that is, in bringing to you the Good News of the Kingdom.
Wishing you well,
Agape, Alan.
john1one@earthlink.net
http://www.goodcompanionbooks.com
Posted by Kimberly at Echowood on May 30, 2008 at 8:57 am
Hi Alan,
Thanks so much for reading and taking the time to comment on this post. It’s hard not to view a visit from a Jehovah’s Witness as an attempt to “convert” because of the way they continue to point out verses in the Bible and offer reading materials even after learning that the person they are speaking to is a Bible reader and Christian already. It’s as if to say, “Yes, well, that’s nice, but your brand of Christianity isn’t good enough. Here’s the TRUTH!” And I can understand that, actually, because it’s how I feel, too, as a Catholic, when I speak to non-Catholics: “I’m very glad for you that you attend church and love the Lord and read your Bible; but your church doesn’t have the fullness of the TRUTH!”
This is why so many people think they dislike Christians—because we think we have the “only way to God.” We don’t go for the “many paths to God” idea. Unfortunately, we Christians are so incredibly lacking in unity. We are the Body of Christ, but we sure don’t act like it. All our disputes and disagreements—we’re His Body, and we’re ripping Him limb from limb. It’s terrible.
Remember how the Lord prayed that all would be One, as He and the Father are One? Part of the reason I became Catholic is that it is the Universal church, it’s not sectarian, it’s for everybody—Christ came to die for all, not just for a select few. Catholics are united under one authority, and the teachings of the Church are long-standing, not shifting with the times and whims of whoever’s in charge (or casting votes) at the moment. And best of all, these teachings are so complex and beautiful; one never tires of meditating on them in light of the Scriptures.
Oh, Alan, how I understand your desire to share your faith! When one feels one has discovered the truth and is truly at a place of complete and utter peace with that, it is so hard not to want to tell the whole world!
As you wish me well, I wish you well, also. May the Lord continue to speak to your heart, to pour out His grace upon you, and bring you closer to Him.
Peace,
Kimberly
Posted by middleman777 on September 19, 2008 at 7:46 pm
Hello, I hope I can offer some assistance/advice to you with talking to JW’s.
There’s many ways to witness to a witness. There’s no particular formula however.
There’s certain doctrinal topics that the typical Christian wants to argue with the average JW about. Doctrines such as Hellfire,Trinity, Immortal soul, etc are well studied by JW’s, many times more than your average born again Christian. The WBTS has been smart on making “answer books” that help them to determine what to say. Some of these are “Insight on the Scriptures”, “Reasoning from the Scriptures”, “What Does The Bible Really Teach”, and the “Aid to Bible Understanding”, etc etc.
Much of the time, unless they have some sort of doubt about the Governing Body or the society itself, your well planned Bible “stumper questions” will be easily avoided and dismissed due to circular reasoning.
If they can be shown how Bethel has lied to them on various doctrines (from their own publications), then they’re forced to reason on their own without the help of an “answer book”.
They don’t have a ready made answer to why they were associated with the UN for 10 years (a big no no), and other political entities such as ANCA, OSCE, CESNUR and why they
have had stocks with companies that make weapons for the US government (RandCam), and why they have had dealings in the occult (with Johannes Greber, the Masons, a demon possessed editor-for one of their older publication series), and why they invented and sold/peddled a occultic device (similar to a Ouija Board) up until the 50’s, and why they misquote their own publications with newer ones etc.
I humbly submit my blog to you as a reference on what I just posted. Here’s the link below…
http://middleman777.wordpress.com/
There should be well enough information to give you a good head start. I’m adding to it all the time.
Blessings………
Posted by middleman777 on September 20, 2008 at 1:41 pm
Thank-you for your response. I hope some of my JW research can help you down the road.
Blessings…..
MM777
http://middleman777.wordpress.com/